Insights & news

Van Bael & Bellis successfully assists Italian canned tomato processors in overturning Australian anti-dumping measures which would have set a dangerous precedent for European processors of agricultural products

  • 06/01/2017
  • News

The Australian Anti-Dumping Review Panel (ADRP) has upheld the appeal brought by Van Bael & Bellis on behalf of two Italian producers of canned tomatoes against a decision of the Australian Anti-Dumping Commission (ADC) imposing definitive antidumping duties on the imports of prepared or preserved tomatoes exported from Italy by Feger di Gerardo Ferraioli SpA and La Doria SpA. Together, these companies account for about 40% of the Australian canned tomato market. Van Bael & Bellis also assisted the Italian government in the preparation of its appeal to the ADRP. 

The ADRP’s decision is of particular significance as it overturns an administrative decision that would have set a dangerous precedent for European processors of agricultural products benefiting from payments granted under the Common Agricultural Policy.

In the original decision, the ADC had concluded that the two producers indirectly benefited from payments (SPS) granted to tomato growers under the Common Agricultural Policy. Accordingly, when determining the normal value for canned tomatoes exported from Italy, the ADC added the full SPS amount to the actual costs for raw tomatoes reported in the two canned tomato producers’ records, thus creating an artificial dumping margin.

In its review, the ADRP accepted Feger’s and La Doria’s argument that the cost adjustment was unjustified since any alleged advantage conferred to growers was not transferred to the processors. The ADRP therefore concluded  that the SPS had no discernible impact on the prices actually paid by the two Italian canned tomato producers for raw tomatoes during the investigation period. Following the review, the duty on La Doria Spa dropped from 4.5% to 0% while that on Feger  di Gerardo Ferrioli Spa decreased from 8.4% to 4.8%.

Van Bael & Bellis partner Fabrizio Di Gianni and associate Gabriele Coppo represented the Italian producers in the proceedings before the Australian ADRP.

Key contacts

Related insights

Sign up for updates
    • 25/02/2019
    • News

    Katharina Bongs is recognized as one of the top women competition law practitioners in their 40s in Europe by [email protected]

    Van Bael & Bellis counsel Katharina Bongs has been selected by a jury at [email protected] as being one of the top 40 women competition lawyers in their 40s who are in private practice in Europe. More than 800 women competition professionals in their 40s were nominated by clients and peers for [email protected]’s “40 in their 40s - Notable Women Competition Professionals in Europe, the Americas and Africa”. The jury for Europe consisted of Prof. Richard Whish (Emeritus Professor of Law at King’s College London), Karin Lunning (Deputy Director General of the Swedish Competition Authority), Nicola Northway (Partner at Baker McKenzie), Prof. Carl Baudenbacher (Former Judge and President of the EFTA Court), Annette Schild (Competition Lawyer), Prof. Philippa Watson (Barrister and Professor of Law at City Law School of University of London), Kaarli H. Eichhorn (Partner at Jones Day), Anne Riley (Head of Shell’s global antitrust team) and Dirk Arts (Partner at Allen & Overy). Further information is available here.

    Read more
    • 17/01/2019
    • News

    Van Bael & Bellis successfully assists Italy in connection with the safeguard investigation with regard to imports of Indica rice from Cambodia and Myanmar

    Van Bael & Bellis successfully assisted Italy in the framework of the safeguard investigation initiated by the European Commission under the Generalised Scheme of Preferences (GSP) Regulation with regard to imports of Indica rice originating in Cambodia and Myanmar. Both Cambodia and Myanmar benefit from the Everything But Arms (EBA) arrangement, which is one of the pillars of the GSP and guarantees tariff-free access to the EU market for all exports, except for weapons and ammunition. With the support of other EU rice-producing Member States, Italy claimed in its request that the significant increase in imports of Indica rice from Cambodia and Myanmar at low prices caused EU growers and millers of Indica rice to experience serious difficulties. At the end of the investigation, the Commission concluded that Indica rice from Cambodia and Myanmar is imported in volumes and at prices which cause serious difficulties to EU producers. Consequently, for the first time since the adoption of the GSP Regulation in 2012, the European Commission decided to make use of the safeguard provisions in the GSP Regulation in order to protect the interests of the EU industry. The common customs duty with regard to imports of Indica rice from Cambodia and Myanmar will be reinstated as from 18 January 2019 for a period of three years, with a progressive reduction in the second and third years of its application. Italy was assisted by Van Bael & Bellis partner Fabrizio Di Gianni, senior associate Aldo Scalini and associate Sofia Gentiloni Silveri. The Commission’s implementing regulation was published in today’s Official Journal.

    Read more
    • 06/11/2018
    • News

    Richard Luff speaks at a conference on trade defence instruments in Brussels

    On 26 October 2018, Van Bael & Bellis partner Richard Luff spoke at a conference on trade defence instruments organized by and held at the Institute for European Studies of the University of Brussels (VUB). Richard’s presentation offered an assessment of the new Article 2(6a) of the Basic Anti-Dumping Regulation in light of the WTO’s Biodiesel rulings.

    Read more

Subscribe to our updates

Please select the practice areas you are interested in: *