Insights & news

Van Bael & Bellis successfully assists Taiwan in its WTO dispute with Canada

  • 22/12/2016
  • News

On 21 December, the Panel issued its report in the WTO dispute between Taiwan and Canada relating to the anti-dumping duties imposed by Canada on imports of carbon steel welded pipes (DS482). Taiwan, assisted by Van Bael & Bellis’ WTO team, prevailed on most of its claims.

The Panel Report contains several important findings with implications going beyond this particular dispute. Specifically, the Panel condemned Canada for failing to terminate the investigation with regard to exporters having a de minimis margin of dumping, i.e. a margin of less than 2% of the export price. The Panel also agreed with Taiwan that imports from such exporters cannot be included in the injury and causation analyses and, as a consequence, cannot be subject to definitive anti-dumping duties. Importantly, the Panel also clarified the authorities’ obligations when dealing with imports from exporters that were not cooperating during the investigation and with new types of products. The Panel rejected Canada’s use of the highest margin found in the course of the entire investigation to establish the margin of dumping for non-cooperating exporters. It also condemned Canada’s use of facts available to determine the anti-dumping duties applicable to new product types that were not previously exported from Taiwan to Canada.

Finally, the Panel found that several provisions of Canada’s underlying legislation are “as such” inconsistent with the Anti-Dumping Agreement and the GATT 1994, meaning that Canada will have to amend its legislation in order to comply with the Panel’s ruling.

Canada now has 60 days to decide whether it will appeal the findings of the Panel.

Key contacts

Related practice areas

Related insights

Sign up for updates
    • 01/07/2020
    • Articles

    European Commission’s White Paper on Levelling the Playing Field as regards Foreign Subsidies

    Key Takeaway: The EU (and Member States) may be given new, far-reaching powers to tackle the perceived harmful effects of third-country subsidies benefitting businesses operating in the EU. Remedies could be imposed limiting participation in all sectors of the internal market, including prohibiting businesses from making subsidised acquisitions and participating in public procurement in the EU. On 17 June 2020, the European Commission (the “Commission”) published a White Paper on how to respond to third countries giving subsidies to companies active in the EU (“foreign subsidies”). In an effort to level the playing field, the Commission proposes new tools to address what it perceives as unfair competition from foreign players in the EU’s internal market. The Commission considers that existing tools, in the areas of notably trade defence, competition law and public procurement, are insufficient to avoid distortions resulting from foreign subsidies. The proposed new tool box fits within the EU’s new policy of “open strategic autonomy”. It signals a more pro-active approach on the part of the EU in responding to unfair and abusive practices distorting the EU internal market and undermining the level playing field.

    Read more
    • 30/04/2020
    • News

    Van Bael & Bellis associate Victor Crochet wins 2019-2020 Society of International Economic Law / Journal of International Economic Law / Oxford University Press Essay Prize

    Van Bael & Bellis associate Victor Crochet has won the 2019-2020 Society of International Economic Law / Journal of International Economic Law / Oxford University Press Essay Prize for his essay titled “China’s ‘Going Global’ Policy: Transnational subsidies under the WTO SCM Agreement”, which he co-authored with Vineet Hegde, a PhD researcher in WTO Law at the Leuven Centre for Global Governance Studies, KU Leuven. The SIEL/JIEL/OUP Prize is awarded for the best essay submitted on any topic in the field of international economic law. The essay is available as a working paper on the website of the Leuven Centre for Global Governance Studies.

    Read more

Subscribe to our updates

Please select the practice areas you are interested in: *