Insights & news

Van Bael & Bellis successfully assists Taiwan in its WTO dispute with Canada

  • 22/12/2016
  • News

On 21 December, the Panel issued its report in the WTO dispute between Taiwan and Canada relating to the anti-dumping duties imposed by Canada on imports of carbon steel welded pipes (DS482). Taiwan, assisted by Van Bael & Bellis’ WTO team, prevailed on most of its claims.

The Panel Report contains several important findings with implications going beyond this particular dispute. Specifically, the Panel condemned Canada for failing to terminate the investigation with regard to exporters having a de minimis margin of dumping, i.e. a margin of less than 2% of the export price. The Panel also agreed with Taiwan that imports from such exporters cannot be included in the injury and causation analyses and, as a consequence, cannot be subject to definitive anti-dumping duties. Importantly, the Panel also clarified the authorities’ obligations when dealing with imports from exporters that were not cooperating during the investigation and with new types of products. The Panel rejected Canada’s use of the highest margin found in the course of the entire investigation to establish the margin of dumping for non-cooperating exporters. It also condemned Canada’s use of facts available to determine the anti-dumping duties applicable to new product types that were not previously exported from Taiwan to Canada.

Finally, the Panel found that several provisions of Canada’s underlying legislation are “as such” inconsistent with the Anti-Dumping Agreement and the GATT 1994, meaning that Canada will have to amend its legislation in order to comply with the Panel’s ruling.

Canada now has 60 days to decide whether it will appeal the findings of the Panel.

Key contacts

Related practice areas

Related insights

Sign up for updates
    • 06/12/2019
    • News

    Tetyana Payosova speaks at a WTI workshop on “Trade Wars and their Impact on Global Trade and Small Economies” in Bern

    On 21 November 2019, Van Bael & Bellis associate Tetyana Payosova spoke at a workshop titled “Trade Wars and their Impact on Global Trade and Small Economies” that was organised by the World Trade Institute of the University of Bern in cooperation with the Chung-Hua Institution for Economic Research. The workshop discussed the rule and role of law in trade wars, the political economy and the economic impact of trade wars on global trade and on small economies. Tetyana’s presentation focused on the role of the WTO dispute settlement system in securing the rule of law, especially in times of trade wars. The panel was chaired by Professor Makane Moise Mbengue, University of Geneva. The other panel members were Niall Meagher (Executive Director, Advisory Centre on WTO Law, Geneva), Professor Michael Hahn (Managing Director, IEW, University of Bern) and Professor Henry Gao (Singapore Management University). Further information on the seminar can be found here

    Read more
    • 24/10/2019
    • News

    Gábor Báthory speaks at the European Federation of Pharmacy Chains’ 1st International Conference on the future of pharmacy care

    On 17 October 2019, Van Bael & Bellis counsel Gábor Báthory spoke at the 1st International Conference on the future of pharmacy care organized by the European Federation of Pharmacy Chains in Prague. Topics covered at the conference included current issues and challenges of the European pharmacy sector such as ownership, quality, education of pharmaceutical professionals and innovation. Gábor's presentation discussed pharmacy ownership, with a focus on remedies available under EU Law against national restrictions on pharmacy ownership. Other speakers included Johan Wallér, CEO of the Swedish Pharmacy Association, Max Müller, Member of the Board at DocMorris, Europe’s largest internet pharmacy, Daniel Horák, CEO of Dr.Max, the largest pharmacy network in Slovakia and the Czech Republic, Peter Pažitný, Executive Director of the “CEE Health Policy Network” and former health policy advisor to various Ministers of Health of Slovakia, the Czech Republic and Hungary, and Tomas Sebek, Co-founder and Partner of uLékaře.cz, the Czech Republic’s leading virtual hospital. The Panel was moderated by Martin Dočkal, the founder and owner of APATYKÁŘ, the largest pharmacy website in the Czech Republic.

    Read more

Subscribe to our updates

Please select the practice areas you are interested in: *