Insights & news

Van Bael & Bellis successfully assists Taiwan in its WTO dispute with Canada

  • 22/12/2016
  • News

On 21 December, the Panel issued its report in the WTO dispute between Taiwan and Canada relating to the anti-dumping duties imposed by Canada on imports of carbon steel welded pipes (DS482). Taiwan, assisted by Van Bael & Bellis’ WTO team, prevailed on most of its claims.

The Panel Report contains several important findings with implications going beyond this particular dispute. Specifically, the Panel condemned Canada for failing to terminate the investigation with regard to exporters having a de minimis margin of dumping, i.e. a margin of less than 2% of the export price. The Panel also agreed with Taiwan that imports from such exporters cannot be included in the injury and causation analyses and, as a consequence, cannot be subject to definitive anti-dumping duties. Importantly, the Panel also clarified the authorities’ obligations when dealing with imports from exporters that were not cooperating during the investigation and with new types of products. The Panel rejected Canada’s use of the highest margin found in the course of the entire investigation to establish the margin of dumping for non-cooperating exporters. It also condemned Canada’s use of facts available to determine the anti-dumping duties applicable to new product types that were not previously exported from Taiwan to Canada.

Finally, the Panel found that several provisions of Canada’s underlying legislation are “as such” inconsistent with the Anti-Dumping Agreement and the GATT 1994, meaning that Canada will have to amend its legislation in order to comply with the Panel’s ruling.

Canada now has 60 days to decide whether it will appeal the findings of the Panel.

Key contacts

Related practice areas

Related insights

Sign up for updates
    • 16/05/2019
    • News

    Pablo Muñiz speaks on customs compliance in the European Union in an interview published online

    Van Bael & Bellis customs partner Pablo Muñiz speaks with Alex Terry of NielsonSmith in an interview recently published online on customs compliance in the European Union. In the interview, Pablo touches upon various topics in the customs sphere, including: low-value consignments and undervaluation in relation to e-commerce, the impact of increased, aggressive customs enforcement on companies, the additional risks posed by trade wars, the harmonisation of customs infringements and penalties, how Brexit has brought the seriousness of customs issues to the fore, the significance of Binding Valuation Rulings and the importance of trade participation in the decision-making process. The interview is available here.

    Read more
    • 15/05/2019
    • News

    Pei Fang Lo speaks at seminars in Taiwan on Taiwanese industries’ response to changes resulting from trade defence measures on electric bicycles from China

    On 6, 7 and 8 May 2019, Van Bael & Bellis senior counsel Pei Fang Lo spoke at three seminars on EU anti-dumping and anti-circumvention investigations: how Taiwanese industries respond to the changes resulting from trade defence measures on electric bicycles originating in China organised by the Chinese National Federation of Industries in the cities of Taipei, Kaohsiung and Taichung in Taiwan. Pei Fang’s presentation offered an introduction to the recent trade defence measures on electric bicycles originating in China, and how Taiwanese industries avoid possible EU investigations by means of trade diversion.

    Read more
    • 15/05/2019
    • News

    Isabelle Van Damme is quoted by Law360 on the impact of Opinion 1/17 on the European Commission’s negotiating position in UNCITRAL

    Isabelle was quoted this week in an article published in Law360 on the Court of Justice of the European Union’s Opinion 1/17 regarding CETA. The article, entitled “EU Investor Court Greenlighted, But May Face Rough Road”, discusses the implications of this opinion on the ongoing negotiations in UNCITRAL aimed at reforming investor-State arbitration mechanisms. In her remarks, Isabelle reflected on the impact of Opinion 1/17 on the European Commission’s negotiating position in those UNCITRAL talks as well as in bilateral negotiations.

    Read more

Subscribe to our updates

Please select the practice areas you are interested in: *