Insights & news

CJEU rules that it has jurisdiction over breaches by a Member State of WTO law

  • 08/10/2020
  • Articles

On 6 October 2020, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued its judgement in Case C-66/18. The case related to the infringement proceedings brought by the Commission against Hungary in relation to its treatment of the Central European University (CEU) and more in general the requirements which Hungary applied to foreign higher education institutions seeking to supply services in its territory. The Court ruled that its jurisdiction in infringement proceedings brought by the European Commission against a Member State on the basis of Article 258 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) extends to a Member State’s failure to fulfil its obligations under World Trade Organization (WTO) law. The CJEU found breaches of the national treatment obligation under the WTO General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), provisions relating to academic freedom, the freedom to found higher education institutions and the freedom to conduct a business in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, and the freedom of establishment and the free movement of services.

The judgment signals that the CJEU may review any Member State measure falling within the scope of the WTO agreements and affecting trade with third States. The reasoning of the CJEU is that those agreements, which are an integral part of EU law, fall within the European Union’s exclusive competence for the common commercial policy (Article 207 TFEU) and the European Union must ensure that it observes its WTO obligations. By exercising jurisdiction in this type of proceeding, the CJEU found that it could contribute to avoiding that the European Union be held responsible for a Member State’s breach of WTO law by the WTO dispute settlement bodies. The CJEU also relied on the consideration that its judgments do not bind the WTO dispute settlement bodies or any third State seeking resort to WTO judicial remedies. The CJEU did not address the distinction between that legal effect of its judgments and the compulsory and exclusive jurisdiction of WTO dispute settlement bodies to resolve disputes between WTO Members, such as Hungary or the European Union and third States, about the interpretation and application of the WTO agreements.

This judgment indicates that third States or economic operators outside the European Union having concerns about a Member State’s compliance with WTO law may now consider the benefits of judicial remedies available under both EU and WTO law. The judgment’s relevance extends also to other international agreements that could be breached as a result of a Member State measure affecting third States or foreign actors. At the same time, the judgment was limited to the context of infringement proceedings. The judgment does not mean that WTO law is now directly applicable and can be invoked by private parties before the CJEU.

The French version of the judgment is available here. An English version will become available at a later date.

Key contacts

Related practice areas

Related insights

Sign up for updates
    • 30/10/2020
    • Articles

    UK and Japan sign Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement

    On 23 October 2020, the United Kingdom (UK) and Japan signed a Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA). The CEPA is based on the Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA) between the European Union (EU) and Japan. However, the CEPA also contains some enhanced provisions in areas such as rules of origin, financial services, and digital matters, and eliminates certain tariff lines earlier than the EPA. Once ratified, the CEPA is expected to enter into force as of 1 January 2021 and, as far as possible, provide continuity for trade between the UK and Japan after the EU-Japan EPA ceases to apply to the UK. Our overview of the UK-Japan CEPA highlights the key features of the agreement and identifies the main differences between the CEPA and the EPA relevant to stakeholders. Please click below to read our note on the UK-Japan Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement.

    Read more
    • 28/10/2020
    • News

    EU FDI Screening Regulation becomes fully applicable

    On 11 October 2020, the EU FDI Screening Regulation[1] entered into force. Adopted in March 2019, it covers EU Member States’ procedures to assess, investigate, authorise, condition, prohibit or unwind foreign direct investment (FDI).

    Read more

Subscribe to our updates

Please select the practice areas you are interested in: *