Insights & news

BITs and FITs: Investment treaty claims arising out of Ukraine’s recent amendments to its FIT scheme

  • 10/11/2021
  • Articles

On 28 October 2021, the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) registered a new request for arbitration proceedings brought against Ukraine by SREW NV (SREW). SREW, which owns the 110-megawatt Dnepro-Bugsky wind power station in southern Ukraine, is claiming that Ukraine’s reforms to its tariff regime are in breach of the BLEU (Belgium-Luxembourg Economic Union) - Ukraine bilateral investment treaty (BIT). This follows the claim earlier in the year by Modus Energy International (Modus Energy), a Lithuanian investor in three solar power plants in Ukraine, which filed SCC arbitration proceedings against Ukraine under the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT). Modus Energy is claiming, by way of its Dutch subsidiary, that Ukraine has breached the ECT through the adoption of Law No. 810-IX, a legislative reform which reduced guaranteed feed-in tariffs (FITs). It is reported that Modus Energy is claiming damages of approximately EUR 11.5 million.

Yet, the claims by SREW and Modus Energy may only be the first set of claims in a potential wave of investment treaty claims, under the ECT or other bilateral investment treaties, that Ukraine may face over recent amendments to its FIT regime. Elementum Energy, a UK investor, has already filed a notice of dispute under both the ECT and the UK-Ukraine BIT and it is reported that investors from Norway, South Korea and Turkey are also considering or have already filed similar trigger letters in response to Ukraine’s legislative reforms.

In this Client Alert, we discuss the recent legislative reforms to Ukraine’s FIT regime which have already given rise to the disputes referred to above. We also consider the claims which Ukraine could face in the context of similar claims which other States have faced in response to the reduction in FITs.

Attachments:

Key contacts

Related practice areas

Related insights

Sign up for updates
    • 20/06/2022
    • News

    Opinion 1/20: Belgium’s request is inadmissible but CJEU still confirms its decision in Komstroy that intra-EU ECT arbitration is incompatible with EU law

    On 16 June 2022, the Court of Justice of the European Union (“CJEU”) published Opinion 1/20, concluding that Belgium’s request for an opinion on the draft modernised Energy Charter Treaty’s (“ECT”) compatibility with EU law is inadmissible. The Court’s Opinion was in response to Belgium’s request for an opinion submitted on 2 December 2020, in which Belgium had asked whether the draft modernised ECT is compatible with EU law. Although refusing to opine directly on Belgium’s questions, the Court highlighted that it had already answered the question of the compatibility of Article 26 of the ECT with European Union (“EU”) law in disputes between investors of one EU Member State and another EU Member State (“intra-EU disputes”). In doing so, the CJEU effectively confirmed its earlier judgment in Case C-741/19, Republic of Moldova v. Komstroy LLC (see our client alert here) which had – even if as an obiter dictum – expressly dealt with the arbitration provisions in the ECT as currently in force.

    Read more
    • 13/06/2022
    • News

    Nicholas A. Lawn recognised in the 11th edition (2023) of The Best Lawyers in the United Kingdom

    Van Bael & Bellis is pleased to announce that Nicholas Lawn, our Head of International Arbitration, has been recognised in the 11th edition (2023) of The Best Lawyers in the United Kingdom™. Nick is ranked for his work in international arbitration. Since it was first published in 1983, Best Lawyers® has become one of the most respected guides to the legal profession globally, publishing its annual survey based on peer-review.

    Read more
    • 18/05/2022
    • News

    Investor-State Claims against Mexico: Recent Developments in the Energy and Mining Sectors

    As an update to our August 2021 client alert, this client alert provides an overview of the most recent regulatory developments in the energy and mining sectors in Mexico and their potential effect on foreign investments.

    Read more

Subscribe to our updates

Please select the practice areas you are interested in: *