Insights & news

Belgium - Constitutional Court Rejects Request for Suspension of Key Provisions of Latest Medicine Shortages Law

  • 20/07/2020
  • Articles

On 16 July 2020, the Constitutional Court rejected several requests for suspension of Articles 2, 3 and 4 of the Law of 20 December 2019 modifying various laws to tackle medicine shortages (Wet van 20 december 2019 tot wijziging van diverse wetgevingen wat de tekorten aan geneesmiddelen betreft/Loi du 20 décembre 2020 modifiant diverses législations, en ce qui concerne les pénuries de medicaments – the Law – see attachments). The requests had been introduced by the Belgian Association of Parallel Importers and Exporters, various other parties active in the parallel trade in medicines and pharmacists in the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Rwanda (the Applicants).
The challenged provisions, broadly, created the following rules: 

  • They tightened the notification requirement of temporary medicine supply cessations.
  • They equated a partial or interrupted supply of medicines to wholesaler-suppliers and pharmacists with a temporary cessation of supplies that gives rise to notification.
  • Medicines affected by notifiable supply cessations may be made subject to a temporary export limitation or prohibition. A Royal Decree is supposed to determine detailed rules, but has not yet been adopted.
  • Wholesalers with a public service obligation and pharmacists started to benefit from a supply obligation of three working days in their favour (see, Van Bael & Bellis Life Sciences News Alerts of 20 December 2019 and 3 February 2020).

The Applicants objected to what they regarded as an illegal export prohibition of medicines and maintained that this prohibition essentially replicated a similar export ban which the Constitutional Court had found to be illegal as an unjustifiable restriction of trade between Member States (see, Van Bael & Bellis Life Sciences News Alerts of 19 July 2019 and 17 October 2019). By contrast, the Belgian government was confident that a focused export restrictions procedure that may result in narrow export limitations would pass muster under European law.

The Constitutional Court sided with the Belgian government and reached the conclusion that the new export prohibition is not similar to the blanket export prohibition which it annulled. However, it did not proceed with an assessment of the merits of the new export ban and its attendant provisions and declined to suspend the challenged provisions because the applicants failed to show that the application of these provisions would cause them serious harm which is difficult to repair.


Key contacts

Related practice areas

Related insights

Sign up for updates
    • 31/07/2020
    • Articles

    British Medical Journal Publishes Critical Review of Orphan Medicines Rules Ahead of Release of European Commission's Own Studies

    As part of the preparatory work for its Pharmaceutical Strategy for Europe which is due in the fourth quarter of 2020, the European Commission (the Commission) is expected to publish shortly an external study and own work assessing the regulatory framework governing orphan medicines and the paediatric rules.

    Read more
    • 28/07/2020
    • Articles

    US President Signs Executive Order Implementing International Pricing Index Model

    On 24 July 2020 the US President signed four executive orders designed to lower medicine prices in the United States (see, attached press release). One of these orders, which has not yet been made publicly available, implements a form of international reference pricing and “take[s] action to ensure that the Medicare program and seniors pay no more for [a series of costly medicines] than any economically comparable OECD country, ending foreign countries’ free loading off the backs of American taxpayers and pharmaceutical investments” (the “International Pricing Index Model” or “IPI Model”).

    Read more
    • 23/07/2020
    • Articles

    Belgium - Belgian Competition Authority Offers Guidance on Mergers of Local Hospital Networks

    On 22 July 2020, the Belgian Competition Authority (BCA) published a note (the Note) which discusses the application of the Belgian merger control rules to the creation of local hospital networks (locoregionale ziekenhuisnetwerken; réseaux hospitaliers locorégionaux – see the attached Note and press release in different language versions).

    Read more

Subscribe to our updates

Please select the practice areas you are interested in: *